Snapshot
ConsentStack is a modern alternative to CookieYes for website consent management. More regulations, more integrations, and your banner never stops working.
Pricing
CookieYes looks affordable at $10/month. But geo-targeting costs $25/month per domain. Branding removal costs $55/month per domain. Every domain is a separate subscription. ConsentStack Pro starts at $29/month with 2 domains included and $5/month per additional domain. Here's what you actually pay.
- 30,000 visitors/mo
- Geo-detection on every tier
- 6 ad platform integrations
- Branding removed
- Customize every detail
- Custom CSS/JS, headless mode
- 2 domains included, $5/mo add-on
- No overage charges
- 300,000 pageviews/mo
- Geo-targeting (not on Free/Basic)
- 3 ad platform integrations
- Branding removal requires $55/mo
- Limited customization options
- Custom CSS (no headless mode)
- $25/mo per domain
- Banner suspends at limit
Your banner never goes dark
ConsentStack has no per-pageview billing and no banner suspension on paid tiers. CookieYes suspends the banner when pageview limits are hit. A compliance tool that causes non-compliance. On ConsentStack Pro, if you exceed 30K visitors, you're auto-upgraded on the next billing cycle. Your banner keeps working.
$25/mo per domain adds up fast
CookieYes charges $25/month per domain. Add www.example.com and app.example.com and you're paying $50/month. Five client sites on CookieYes Pro = $125/month. ConsentStack Pro includes 2 domains at $29/month, with additional domains at $5/month each. Five domains on ConsentStack = $44/month. That's a $81/month difference that only grows with every domain you add.
The features you need aren't extras
CookieYes gates geo-targeting at $25/mo, branding removal at $55/mo, and color customization behind any paid plan. ConsentStack includes geo-detection on free, removes branding at $29/mo, and gives you full visual customization on every tier.
“They trapped us with a good free tier and now they are making it worse and worse every year... they are removing stuff EVERY YEAR from it, I'm done.”
kroups, WordPress.org reviewer, Feb 2026Source for CookieYes prices: cookieyes.com/pricing. CookieYes Ultimate ($55/mo) is required for branding removal.
Compliance
Enable Global Compliance Mode (one toggle) and 195+ privacy regulations across 157+ jurisdictions apply automatically. No region configuration, no jurisdiction research, no manual rule mapping. A visitor from Germany gets GDPR treatment, a visitor from California gets CCPA/CPRA, a visitor from Brazil gets LGPD. All from a single setting, on every tier including free.
CookieYes claims “130+ countries” on its features page but publishes 11 named regulatory frameworks on the homepage and no per-jurisdiction consent model mapping. Their geo-targeting requires the Pro tier ($25/month). Without it, EU and US visitors see the same banner, which means the same consent model for jurisdictions that require fundamentally different treatment. That's not a feature limitation. It's a compliance gap.
“A free plan that at a certain point hits you up for money otherwise they disable the cookie banner.”
campanellafoto (Michael), WordPress.org reviewer, Jan 2026ConsentStack covers all 20 US state privacy laws with automatic per-state resolution via a single toggle. CookieYes documents roughly 5 US state laws and appears to treat US states as a single category rather than enforcing per-state consent models.
“CookieYes admin panel shows ~900 visits, Search Console shows ~600, GA4 shows ~80 (!!!)”
u/KitchenCarrot1, r/Wordpress, Mar 2026Without geo-targeting, every visitor sees a GDPR-style opt-in banner, including visitors in jurisdictions with no consent requirement. The result is unnecessary consent friction and a collapse in analytics data. ConsentStack's geo-detection shows the right consent experience to the right visitor, maximizing opt-in rates where consent is needed and showing no banner where it isn't.
Platform
CookieYes started as a WordPress plugin called “Cookie Law Info” in 2012. WordPress is where it shines: 1 million active installs, responsive support, five-minute setup. But the product's strength is also its ceiling. Outside WordPress, CookieYes is a script tag you paste into your site. No headless mode, no REST API, no event system beyond a single cookieyes_banner_loaded event. The Banner Action API offers three actions, and setting partial consent requires manipulating DOM checkboxes by element ID.
“CookieYes plugin is causing issues on my WordPress sites. Sometimes it blocks Elementor forms, slows down or completely breaks page loading.”
u/KitchenCarrot1, r/elementor, Apr 2025Even within WordPress, CookieYes's auto-blocking causes breakage that costs real money. One user reported Gravity Forms payment fields stopped working, costing “$10,000+ in business.” ConsentStack blocks against a library of 5,800+ known tracker domains and lets you override any decision.
ConsentStack works identically across WordPress, React, Next.js, Shopify, and any site that can include a script tag. One script, full JavaScript API. getConsent, setConsent, hasConsent, onConsentChange, showBanner, showPreferences, event listeners, command queue, and headless mode on Pro. The same SDK, the same behavior, regardless of platform.
Ad platform signaling that covers your stack
ConsentStack signals consent to 6 ad platforms: Google, Meta, TikTok, Microsoft, Pinterest, and LinkedIn. CookieYes signals to 3: Google, Microsoft, and Facebook. If you run ads on TikTok, Pinterest, or LinkedIn alongside CookieYes, those platforms never learn whether a visitor consented. Your ad reporting suffers and you lose insight into what's working.
Customization
CookieYes gives you a color picker and a logo upload. ConsentStack gives you a design system. The difference matters when your banner needs to match a brand, not just approximate one.
Full control over banner text
ConsentStack lets you edit every line of banner copy, including per-consent-model overrides so GDPR visitors see different messaging than CCPA visitors. CookieYes auto-generates banner text and provides limited editing. Their v3.4.0 release (January 2026) removed color customization from the free tier entirely.
Visual builder, not a settings page
ConsentStack's visual builder offers 12 color tokens, 5 banner layouts, 4 preferences center layouts, and live preview. CookieYes offers basic color and position controls with no layout options and no live preview. Most customization requires their Ultimate tier at $55/month.
CSS, JS, and headless mode when you need them
When the visual builder isn't enough, ConsentStack Pro includes custom CSS/JS injection and headless mode for fully custom UIs. CookieYes supports custom CSS but discourages it because their class names change between releases. No JavaScript injection. No headless mode. No way to build your own consent experience on top of their SDK.
For Developers
Performance
CookieBench benchmarked CookieYes at 147ms First Contentful Paint , the slowest of any CMP tested. DebugBear measured CookieYes at 81ms INP, 7th of 11 CMPs. Agence Web Performance found CookieYes injects ~140 DOM nodes (67% more than the 84-node average). With IAB TCF enabled, users have documented 48,000 DOM elements and the banner becoming the Largest Contentful Paint element at 6.5 seconds on mobile. ConsentStack's SDK is a single 23KB gzipped file. Banner appears in ~50ms. Zero external dependencies. CSS scoped with cs- prefix. Config cached in localStorage with 24hr TTL.
“Our websites were very slow on mobile after installing the banner... Only solution they offered (after 1000's of euros investigation costs) was to restrict the vendors list.”
Jeroen S., Director, Retail. Capterra reviewer, Feb 2025API
CookieYes's Banner Action API provides 3 actions: accept_all, reject, and accept_partial. Setting partial consent requires document.getElementById("ckySwitchanalytics").checked = true before calling the function. That's brittle DOM manipulation that breaks if CookieYes changes element IDs. No headless mode, no webhook system, no REST API. ConsentStack provides getConsent, setConsent, hasConsent, onConsentChange, showBanner, showPreferences, on/off event listeners, a command queue for pre-load calls, and headless mode on Pro for fully custom UIs.
Source: CookieBench, DebugBear, and Agence Web Performance independent CMP benchmarks.
Consent management that keeps up.
195+ regulations, 6 ad integrations, and no banner suspension. From $29/mo.
FAQ
ConsentStack covers 195+ privacy regulations with automatic geo-detection on every tier, including free. That's a feature CookieYes gates behind its Pro plan at $25/month. For sites that have outgrown a basic cookie banner and need jurisdiction-aware consent, multi-platform ad signaling, and predictable pricing, ConsentStack is built for that next step.
CookieYes starts lower at $10/month for Basic, but charges $25/month per domain for geo-targeting. Five domains on CookieYes Pro = $125/month. ConsentStack Pro starts at $29/month with 2 domains included and $5/month per additional domain. Five domains = $44/month. ConsentStack also includes branding removal, 6 ad platform integrations, and no overage charges at that price.
Only on the Pro plan ($25/month) and above. CookieYes's geo-targeting feature, which shows different banners based on visitor location, requires Pro. On Free and Basic plans, all visitors see the same banner regardless of jurisdiction. ConsentStack includes jurisdiction-aware consent on every tier, automatically showing opt-in to EU visitors and opt-out to US visitors.
Yes. Add a single script tag to your site, configure your banner in the visual builder, and publish. The SDK handles geo-detection, script blocking, and consent logging automatically. CookieYes consent records don't transfer (no CMP supports cross-platform consent migration), but new consent is collected from the first pageview.
ConsentStack blocks scripts at the source rather than scanning for cookies after they're set. The SDK automatically classifies third-party scripts against a library of 5,800+ known tracker domains and blocks them before execution until consent is granted. This prevents cookies from being set in the first place, rather than detecting them after the fact. Site owners can also define custom script rules for any domain not in the library.
It depends on your site. CookieYes's free tier covers 5,000 pageviews with a basic banner, but it lacks geo-targeting (so EU and US visitors see the same consent experience), color customization (as of v3.4.0, January 2026), multilingual support, and scheduled cookie scanning. If your site serves international traffic or needs to differentiate consent by region, the free tier has compliance gaps that require upgrading to Pro ($25/month).
If extra pageviews aren't enabled, CookieYes suspends your consent banner entirely. Cookies and trackers load without consent. CookieYes's own documentation confirms alerts at 80%, 95%, and 100% of the limit, followed by suspension. ConsentStack never suspends the banner on paid tiers. On Pro, exceeding the visitor cap triggers an auto-upgrade on the next billing cycle. Your banner keeps working.
Any CMP that properly blocks analytics until consent will reduce GA4 reported traffic. This is by design, not a bug. Reddit threads show CookieYes users reporting 65–80% drops in GA4 data. ConsentStack minimizes this through automatic geo-detection: visitors in jurisdictions with no consent requirement see no banner, so analytics fire normally. Consent-mode signaling to Google also enables GA4's behavioral modeling to fill gaps from users who don't consent.
Related Comparisons
Evaluating other consent management platforms? See how ConsentStack compares.
